Euthyphro Essay, Research Paper
Euthyphro
The beginning of the story was easy to understand. I could picture
Euthyphro walking up and asking Socrates what he had been doing at the
palace. He didn?t seem to be too surprised to hear that Socrates was being
impeached.
I?m not sure what I think about Euthyphro prosecuting his own
father. I suppose that for the sake of justice, it would be the right thing to
do. To judge him on terms of piety, I would have no clue how to do that. I
wasn?t really sure exactly what piety was when I began reading the story.
Quite honestly, I didn?t receive an answer either. I found myself being
pulled into the circles that Euthyphro was pulled into.
It is somewhat humorous how Socrates goes about asking Euthyphro
about the meaning of piety. He actually seems a bit condescending in his
questioning, but Euthyphro didn?t seem to notice. His character seemed to
be pleased in being thought of as an expert on the matter of piety (and
impiety). I don?t believe that Socrates expected to receive a definite answer
to his questions. The whole point seemed to be an attempt to make
Euthyphro really think about his own definitions and his position in
prosecuting his own father.
Socrates somewhat lures Euthyphro into thinking they are coming
from the same angle. It is amusing the way Socrates makes himself appear
to be a student of Euthyphro. Any reader should be able to tell after a
short time who the wiser man is.
In the very beginning of the questioning, I could actually follow
along. I understood exactly what was being said. I could also see the
entrapment that Socrates was heading toward. As an outsider, reading
with th
brought Euthyphro around in circles. As I got further into the story, I also
became lost and was forced to reread many different paragraphs. As
Socrates pulled Euthyphro further into confusion, I also felt more confused.
I do think I was able to sort out a few points, though.
I understood the question raised concerning issues that were loved
and hated by the gods. It was a good idea. In a polytheistic society, how
could the people choose which issues to follow, if some were to be loved by
certain gods and hated by others? Euthyphro didn?t actually answer that
question well. He reverted to his own trial against his father.
I became totally lost in the whole discussion of carrying, becoming,
and suffering. I tried to sort through that multiple times, but couldn?t seem
to grasp his point. I?m not really sure Euthyphro ever understood that part
either.
I did understand the point made about holy, loved, and dear.
Euthyphro thought he understood them too, but when Socrates brought
them up in the end, they were right back at the beginning where they
started.
Even though Socrates never got a definite answer from Euthyphro
concerning piety and impiety, I believe he accomplished his goal. I truly
don?t think he ever expected to walk away with a sound interpretation of
piety and impiety. Perhaps he already knew the correct meanings. The
goal of the conversation could have simply been to confuse Euthyphro into
confronting his own ideas and beliefs. I would have been frustrated in that
situation. I have been in a class before when no one seemed to understand
my questions, and the questions went unanswered.