Civil Action Essay, Research Paper
The movie brings up an interesting idea that many people in the public don’t see
or hear about very often. The idea that the big corporations often don’t take
into account the safety of the people that work for them or the people that live
around the factories. These big corporations are run entirely by money and the
idea of what things will cost and how much money they can possibly make. Too
many times money is more important than the lives of human beings and the people
that run these places only see in dollars and cents. The moral issues that this
dilemma brings up are immense. This has been happening for centuries since the
industrial revolution. Workers were subjected too harsh conditions and unsafe
factories so that more goods could be produced. They had children as young as
seven and eight years old working 15 hour days. In our modern times, toxic waste
now plays a big part in the safety of people. The waste that these companies
produce and dump under our noses don’t seem to bother them in the least. The way
microeconomics effects this must be fully explored to realize the way the
corporate world thinks and acts. The goal of any corporation is to make the
maximum profit that they can providing a good or service to the community while
doing it as inexpensively as possible to them. Too many times producing these
goods, toxic by-products are also produced. Nuclear power plants create
plutonium, factories let poisonous gasses into the atmosphere, and chemicals are
dumped into the drains and washed into our water everyday while being unknown to
the people around them. The issue then becomes what to do with these
"poisons" at the cheapest cost to retain the most revenue. In A Civil
Action the W.R. Grace company decided that the best place to dump the T.C.E. was
in the river behind the plant. It’s too bad that all the people who lived down
stream were also effected by the carelessness of this company. It got into the
drinking water and gave kids cancer and seizures among other health conditions.
These companies try to cover up these kinds of things as much as possible by
buying people off. They think that if they give people money for their losses
than everything will be alright. For huge corporations dealing with billions of
dollars these payoffs are only a drop in the bucket for them. Even a million
dollars to any family is an incredible amount of money and often the money
becomes more important than the real issues behind the problem and can’t be
passed up by a family struggling to get by. The benefits of paying of these
people for their trouble is much cheaper then doing things the right way in the
beginning and protecting their safety. Money in our society has become a sense
of power and authority. People think to many times that money is the key to
happiness. Althoug
causes them to not care about the things that they should many times.
Corporations have a structure that they follow in order to make them run in an
efficient manner. In the movie John Travolta initially doesn’t want to take the
case because he doesn’t think that there will be any money in it for him and his
firm. Even though he goes and sees how much pain this company has caused to the
people in Wolburn, he still doesn’t care because of the money. Not until he
realizes how big the companies are does he take the case. As the case goes on he
isn’t able to achieve what he ultimately wanted to do because the Grace Company
has so much money that it will almost always win. Travolta’s firm goes eight
million into debt trying to win this case but ultimately has to settle because
they can’t go on. The firm doesn’t even have to clean up the polluted land that
caused all the problems. It wasn’t until the E.P.A. steps in and with their
power was able to achieve a proper sanction to this company. This is not the
only issue that the W.R. Grace company has tried to cover up. They produced and
insulation called zonolite which contained asbestos. They were worried that a
label on the insulation would hurt sales of the product so they fought hard to
keep the labels off so that they wouldn’t be breaking the law. They knew as far
back as 1963 that the insulation was harmful to people yet produced it until
1984. The Grace company is a 1.5 billion multinational chemical and construction
products company. With money like that these companies have so much power that
it makes them seem like they are above the law sometimes. Not only this company
but other construction companies often look past safety in order to save money.
Thankfully organizations like O.S.H.A. have been developed in order to protect
the safety of the American worker from the power of these companies. O.S.H.A.
sets national standards for industry in order to provide a safe and helpful work
environment for workers. Microeconomics is a powerful factor in the way that
companies handle their business. Money runs these companies from the ground up
and often is more important than the people that work there. These companies try
to weigh out the costs and benefits of these actions. For a billion dollar
company to change the way they do things in order to be safe will cost them too
much money many times so they decide that it is more cost efficient to pay off
the injured parties with a nominal amount of money. Unfortunately that is the
way the corporate world works nowadays, but with organizations such as O.S.H.A.
and others these huge companies that have held all the power for years are
finally being set in their place. These corporations need to value the lives of
people more than the paper that money is printed on.
320